IBA Position
Background
The Farm Credit System (FCS) is a $373 billion government-sponsored enterprise (GSE) that competes against private-sector, tax-paying institutions in making loans to farmers/ranchers, consumers and businesses. If the FCS were a bank, it would be in the Top 10 largest in the United States by domestic asset size, according to Federal Reserve data.
Created out of federal legislation enacted in 1916, the purpose of the FCS is to provide credit to small local farmers and ranchers. Amendments authorized in 1980 underscore that purpose by recognizing the FCS’s commitment to “young, beginning and small” (YBS) farmers.
Issues
The Farm Credit System has strayed from its mission of supporting small American farmers. Instead, the FCS acts as an investment institution, funding profitable entities unrelated to agriculture, such as golf courses, franchised restaurants, colleges and, most infamously, telecommunications giants, while diminishing its service to YBS farmers.
The tax-exempt status of the FCS gives it an unfair edge when competing against community banks for loans, since Farm Credit lenders can undercut local lenders with lower rates. Furthermore, the Farm Credit Services structure as a government-sponsored enterprise creates an environment where government is effectively competing against the free market. These activities hinder the lending ability of tax-paying community banks.
Key Messages
The Time for Reform Is Now
- Congress should abolish the FCS’s tax subsidy. It does not help the economy, make the tax code fairer or promote an important policy goal. With $373 billion in assets and more than $8 billion in profits annually, the FCS is capable of paying its fair share of taxes.
- Congress should restructure Farm Credit Services away from a retail GSE into acting as more of a partner with financial institutions.
Additional Resources
IBA Government Relations Staff
Dax Denton